Our enemies may laugh at our hand wringing, but it is the very inhumanity and chaos, the inability to use diplomacy and appreciate peace, that we disdain in them and struggle against when it is directed towards us and the innocent among them.
If the captive were diabetic, it would be torture to withhold his insulin until he talks, since this would fit our characterization of torture as a form of coerced trade.
Targeted killings Several basic positions have emerged. If bombs seem too impersonal an evil, picture your seven-year-old daughter being slowly asphyxiated in a warehouse just five minutes away, while the man in your custody holds the keys to her release.
Even a state that allows torture only in rare cases will soon insist on competent torturers; hence torture schools, torture experts, torture research, and, given the gravity of the matter, an administrative state structure to oversee it all. But, drinking too much water can result in water intoxication.
This intuition may help you decide but, even after integrating the moral relevance of family, it still violates the deontological constraint of treating torture as a universal moral wrong: So much so, in fact, that even asking why seems immoral, as if merely speaking of a ghost might make it appear.
I thought the sign said Ferris wheel! Never mind the fragility of a proposition that is both unprovable and falsifiable. For those who make it their business to debate the ethics of torture this is known as the "ticking-bomb" case.
Chinese Water Torture Surprisingly, there is no evidence of the chinese people lending their name to this popular torture. B Interrogation methods would have done the same thing My opponent says two things in response. Moral systems consist mostly of intuitive, a priori judgments, unshackled from the need for empirical validation.
As dissenters noted, the Court could have punished the cop for breaking the rules, rather than rewarding the criminal. That alone justifies a total ban on torture. I am one of the few people I know of who has argued in print that torture may be an ethical necessity in our war on terror.
There is no escaping the fact that whenever we drop bombs, we drop them with the knowledge that some number of children will be blinded, disemboweled, paralyzed, orphaned, and killed by them. It is morally imperative for her to renounce any ethical code and take full responsibility for her choice—or, as an existentialist would put it, to admit that she is condemned to be free.
Some say a society that allows torture loses its soul and brings shame on its members. Because grotesquely evil behavior must be criminalized? As a moral matter, I am categorically opposed to torture, without exception. Pain and death do not explain why torture feels so evil.
Furthermore, my opponent concedes that waterboarding has only been used on three individuals and only one actually revealed anything. Tap here to turn on desktop notifications to get the news sent straight to you.
The first issue to address is consistency.Aug 03, · The reasons why torture is wrong can be divided into reasons of pure principle and reasons based on the bad consequences of torture.
Such a law would implicitly legitimate torture in extreme situations, and that’s a bad thing, but it would also create visibility and accountability, which is a good thing.
Dec 29, · Torture is good for producing fear, but not good for gathering intelligence. Numerous intelligence agencies agree, asshole.
And since you have nothing new to say on the matter, save your effort to.
Why Torture is a Good Thing. Recently the Speaker of the House of Representatives, Nancy Pelosi has come under fire for comments she made about torture, once again bringing the topic of torture back into the national spotlight.
Apparently it's true: you can have too much of a good thing. Water intoxication encompasses muscle weakness, cramping, nausea, and vomiting. Eventually, cells in the brain will swell, resulting in seizures, comas, brain damage, and death.
A door opens up on a sickening chamber of horror. and all that Obama can say is that torture is good; yea, it is even salvific, it saves lives, it is good and effective and necessary and we need it.
Torture is good. That is Barack .Download